Floating Knee Injury
FLOATING KNEE INJURY
Ipsilateral Femur + Tibia | Fraser Classification | High-Energy Polytrauma
Fraser Classification
Critical Must-Knows
- Fraser Classification: Type I (both extra-articular = best), IIA (tibial articular), IIB (femoral articular), IIC (both = worst)
- Ligamentous injury in 50%+ - often missed initially due to swelling/pain. Always reassess and MRI when stable
- Stabilise BOTH fractures - typically IM nails if extra-articular. Same sitting reduces complications
- Damage control if patient unstable: spanning external fixation of both, definitive fixation when resuscitated
- Vascular injury and compartment syndrome (thigh AND leg) must be assessed
Examiner's Pearls
- "Femur first usually preferred - restores limb length, facilitates tibial reduction
- "Type IIC (both articular) has worst prognosis - complex surgical management required
- "Knee stiffness is common complication - early mobilisation essential
- "Open fractures common in this high-energy pattern
Clinical Imaging
Imaging Gallery


Exam Warning
Fraser Classification
Articular = Bad. Type I (Extra-articular) is best. Type IIC (Both articular) is worst.
Hidden Injury
Ligaments. Greater than 50% have ACL/PCL tears. Often missed due to swelling/pain.
Double Danger
Compartment Syndrome. Assess BOTH thigh and leg compartments closely.
At a Glance
Floating knee injury describes ipsilateral femur and tibia fractures creating an unstable knee segment disconnected from axial skeleton. It results from high-energy trauma (MVA, motorcycle accidents) with associated injuries in 80% and mortality of 5-15%. The Fraser classification determines prognosis: Type I (both extra-articular, best prognosis), Type IIA (tibial articular), Type IIB (femoral articular), Type IIC (both articular, worst prognosis). Management involves stabilization of both fractures, typically with intramedullary nailing if extra-articular. Critical associated injuries include ligamentous knee injury (greater than 50%, often missed initially), vascular injury requiring angiography, and compartment syndrome in both thigh and leg.
I-ABCFraser Classification
Memory Hook:I-ABC: I for extra-articular (Individual bones), ABC for articular (A=tibia, B=femur, C=Combined)
CLVNFloating Knee Assessment
Memory Hook:CLVN: Check Limbs, Vessels, Nerves for compartment and vascular safety
F-T-SManagement Sequence
Memory Hook:F-T-S: Femur restores length, Tibia follows, Same sitting for efficiency
Overview
Floating knee injury describes ipsilateral fractures of the femur and tibia, creating an unstable knee segment that is disconnected from the axial skeleton. The term reflects the biomechanical reality that the knee "floats" free between two fracture sites.
Epidemiology
- Incidence: Accounts for 2-4% of lower extremity fractures
- Demographics: Male predominance (3:1), peak age 20-40 years
- Mechanism: High-energy trauma (MVA 70%, motorcycle 20%, pedestrian vs vehicle 5%)
- Polytrauma association: Present in 70-80% of cases
- Mortality: 5-15% (usually from associated injuries)
- Open fracture rate: 30-40%
Associated Injuries
| Injury Type | Incidence | Clinical Significance |
|---|---|---|
| Knee ligament injury | 50-70% | Often missed initially, affects rehabilitation |
| Vascular injury | 5-10% | Limb-threatening, requires urgent assessment |
| Compartment syndrome | 10-20% | Both thigh and leg at risk |
| Ipsilateral hip/ankle | 15-20% | Must image entire limb |
| Head/chest/abdominal | 40-60% | ATLS priorities |
Anatomy and Biomechanics
Relevant Anatomy
Knee as the "Floating" Segment:
- The knee joint and surrounding soft tissues become an unstable segment
- Disconnected superiorly by femur fracture and inferiorly by tibia fracture
- Popliteal vessels and nerves traverse this zone
Critical Vascular Anatomy:
- Popliteal artery: Fixed at adductor hiatus proximally and soleus arch distally
- Tethered position makes it vulnerable to traction injury
- Intimal tears may cause delayed thrombosis
Muscular Attachments:
- Quadriceps mechanism spans the femur fracture
- Gastrocnemius origin crosses the knee
- These contribute to deforming forces and stiffness
Biomechanical Considerations
Deforming Forces:
- Femur: Proximal fragment abducted and flexed (iliopsoas, abductors)
- Tibia: Variable depending on fracture level
- Knee tends toward flexion contracture if not mobilized early
Load Transmission:
- Normal: Axial load through femur → knee → tibia
- Floating knee: Complete loss of axial stability
- Requires fixation of BOTH fractures for weight-bearing
Classification Systems
Fraser Classification
| Type | Femur | Tibia | Prognosis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Type I | Shaft (Extra-articular) | Shaft (Extra-articular) | Best (75-85% Excellent) |
| Type IIA | Shaft | Articular (Plateau) | Moderate (60-70% Good) |
| Type IIB | Articular (Condyle) | Shaft | Poor (55-65% Good) |
| Type IIC | Articular (Condyle) | Articular (Plateau) | Worst (45-55% Good) |
The Fraser system remains the definitive classification for these injuries.
Clinical Assessment
Initial Trauma Evaluation
ATLS Priorities:
- High-energy polytrauma focus
- Associated injuries in 80% (Head, Chest, Abdo)
- Hemodynamic stability assessment first
Limb Assessment:
- Obvious deformity and length discrepancy
- Skin integrity (open fractures common)
- Compartment Monitoring: Both thigh (3 compartments) and leg (4 compartments)
- Vascular Exam: Popliteal, DP, PT pulses; ABI if suspicious
- Neurological Exam: Peroneal nerve (most vulnerable)
Assessment of the "floating" segment is secondary to life-saving measures.
Investigations
Radiographic Series
Standard Trauma Series:
- Full-length femur (AP/Lateral)
- Full-length tibia (AP/Lateral)
- AP Pelvis (check for associated hip fractures)
- Dedicated Knee Series (AP/Lateral/Oblique)
Assessment checklist:
- Identify fracture location (diaphyseal vs articular)
- Assess for comminution
- Check joint congruity
A true lateral of the knee is essential to rule out occult subluxation.
Management Algorithm

Algorithm should be interpreted in context of overall trauma status.
Ligamentous Injury
More than 50% of floating knee injuries have associated knee ligament damage, but this is often occult initially due to swelling and pain. Always assess the knee once fractures are stabilised and obtain MRI when appropriate.
Clinical Context: Ligamentous injury significantly affects rehabilitation and outcomes.
Management
Damage Control vs Definitive
Damage Control Phase (Unstable Patient):
- Spanning external fixation of both femur and tibia
- Temporary stabilisation to allow resuscitation
- Definitive fixation once physiological parameters normalise
Definitive Fixation (Stable Patient):
- Address both fractures at same sitting if possible
- Reduces hospital stay and allows early motion
Fixation Strategies by Fraser Type:
- Fraser Type I: Double IM nailing (Antegrade femur + Tibia)
- Fraser Type IIA: Femur nailing + Tibial plateau ORIF
- Fraser Type IIB: Distal femur ORIF + Tibial nailing
- Fraser Type IIC: Dual ORIF (Distal femur + Tibial plateau)
Fixation strategy must be tailored to specific fracture patterns.
Sequence of Fixation
Most surgeons prefer femur first:
- Restores limb length and gross alignment
- Facilitates subsequent tibial reduction
- More ergonomic patient positioning
Tibial fixation follows immediately to finalize the construct stability.
Surgical Technique
Femoral Techniques
Intramedullary Nailing:
- Entry: Piriformis or greater trochanteric
- Reamed nailing preferred for stability
- Interlocking screws to control rotation
ORIF (Distal Femur):
- Lateral parapatellar approach
- Anatomic articular reduction first
- Locking plate or retrograde nail depending on complexity
Bone quality and comminution dictate the final implant choice.
Complications
Early Complications
Compartment Syndrome (10-20%):
- Affects both thigh AND leg compartments
- Thigh contains 3 compartments (Often overlooked)
- Maintain high index of suspicion with serial evaluations
- Threshold for prophylactic fasciotomy should be low
Vascular Injury (5-10%):
- Popliteal artery most at risk due to tethered anatomy
- May present delayed due to intimal injury
- Requires immediate revascularization if diagnosed
- Limb viability window: 6-8 hours warm ischemia
Infection:
- Higher rates than isolated fractures (10-15%)
- Open fractures require debridement and antibiotics per Gustilo protocol
- External fixation pin site infections
Late Complications
Knee Stiffness (20-50%):
- Most common long-term problem
- Due to periarticular scarring and quadriceps adhesions
- Prevention: Early ROM, avoid prolonged immobilization
- Treatment: Aggressive physiotherapy, consider manipulation under anesthesia
Malunion/Nonunion:
- Both fracture sites at risk
- Smoking, diabetes, and infection increase risk
- May require revision fixation or bone grafting
Post-traumatic Arthritis:
- Particularly prevalent in Fraser Type II injuries
- Articular damage + ligament instability contribute
- May require total knee arthroplasty in the long term
Postoperative Care
Immediate Postoperative
Day 0-3:
- DVT prophylaxis (LMWH)
- Pain management (multimodal analgesia)
- Neurovascular monitoring
- Wound inspection
Early Mobilization:
- CPM or active-assisted ROM from day 1 if stable fixation
- Quadriceps setting exercises
- Ankle pumps
Weight-Bearing Protocol
| Fracture Pattern | Weight-Bearing Status | Duration |
|---|---|---|
| Type I (both IM nails) | Touch weight-bearing → progressive | 6-12 weeks |
| Type II (articular) | Non-weight-bearing → partial | 8-12 weeks |
| External fixation | Non-weight-bearing | Until definitive fixation |
Rehabilitation Phases
Phase 1 (0-6 weeks):
- ROM exercises (goal: 0-90° knee flexion)
- Quadriceps strengthening (isometric initially)
- Gait training with assistive devices
Phase 2 (6-12 weeks):
- Progressive weight-bearing
- Active ROM to full
- Closed chain exercises
- Aquatic therapy if available
**Phase 3 (12+ weeks):
- Full weight-bearing
- Functional training
- Return to activity assessment
- Address remaining ligamentous instability
Outcomes
Functional Recovery
Return to Work:
- 60-70% return to pre-injury occupation
- Average time: 9-12 months
- Manual laborers typically have worse outcomes
Outcome Measures:
- Knee Society Score
- WOMAC
- SF-36
Prognostic Factors (AOA context): Type II injuries (articular) carry a significantly higher burden of post-traumatic OA.
Evidence Base
Fraser Classification and Outcomes
- Original description of floating knee classification
- Type II (articular) injuries had significantly worse outcomes
- Knee stiffness was the most common complication
- Early mobilization improved functional results
Ipsilateral Fractures of the Femur and Tibia
- Study of 57 patients with floating knee injuries
- Advocated for rigid internal fixation of both fractures
- Reported significantly better results with intramedullary nailing
- Complications included infection (12%) and nonunion (5%)
Single-Stage Fixation for Floating Knee
- Single-stage fixation of both fractures is safe and effective
- Reduced hospital stay compared to staged procedures
- No increase in complication rates
- Better functional outcomes with early knee mobilization
Ligamentous Injuries in Floating Knee
- Ligament injuries present in 53% of floating knee cases
- ACL most commonly injured
- Often unrecognized at initial presentation
- Affects long-term knee function
Damage Control Orthopaedics in Polytrauma
- Damage control reduces systemic inflammatory response
- External fixation as temporizing measure
- Definitive fixation when patient optimized
- Reduces ARDS and multi-organ failure
Exam Viva Scenarios
Practice these scenarios to excel in your viva examination
Scenario 1: Fraser Type I Floating Knee - Single-Stage Fixation
"A 28-year-old motorcyclist is brought to ED after a high-speed collision. He has obvious deformity of his left thigh and leg. X-rays show a mid-shaft femur fracture and a proximal tibial shaft fracture. He is haemodynamically stable. How do you manage this?"
Scenario 2: Fraser Type IIC - Complex Articular Injury
"A 35-year-old construction worker falls 4 meters from scaffolding landing on his left leg. X-rays show a comminuted distal femur fracture and a bicondylar tibial plateau fracture (Schatzker VI pattern). How would you approach this challenging injury?"
Scenario 3: Floating Knee with Popliteal Artery Injury - Limb Salvage
"A 42-year-old presents following a motor vehicle accident with a floating knee injury. His left leg is pale and cool with absent pulses. CT angiography confirms popliteal artery transection. How do you manage this?"
MCQ Practice Points
Exam Pearl
Q: What is a floating knee injury and what is the Fraser classification?
A: Floating knee: Ipsilateral fractures of the femur and tibia, isolating the knee segment. Fraser classification: Type I: Diaphyseal fractures of both bones (extra-articular). Type IIa: Tibial plateau involvement (intra-articular tibia). Type IIb: Distal femur involvement (intra-articular femur). Type IIc: Both articular surfaces involved. Type II injuries have worse prognosis due to knee joint involvement.
Exam Pearl
Q: What are the associated injuries to evaluate in floating knee?
A: Vascular injury: Popliteal artery (high risk) - check pulses, ABI, consider CT angiography. Knee ligamentous injury: Up to 50% have ligament damage; Assess after skeletal stabilization. Compartment syndrome: High index of suspicion for both thigh and leg. Soft tissue injury: Open fractures common (30-40%). Systemic trauma: Polytrauma evaluation (head, chest, abdomen) due to high-energy mechanism.
Exam Pearl
Q: What is the surgical treatment strategy for floating knee injuries?
A: Damage control: Temporizing external fixation if hemodynamically unstable. Definitive fixation: Both fractures fixed when patient optimized. Femur first: Usually IMN for diaphyseal fractures. Tibia: IMN for shaft; Plates for plateau. Same-day fixation of both fractures preferred to allow early knee mobilization. Early motion critical to prevent knee stiffness.
Exam Pearl
Q: What are the outcomes and complications specific to floating knee injuries?
A: Knee stiffness: Most common complication (20-50%). Malunion/nonunion: Both fracture sites at risk. Infection: Higher rates with open fractures. Vascular injury: Limb-threatening emergency. Long-term outcomes: Return to work only 60-70%. Knee arthrosis: Common in Type II injuries affecting articular surfaces.
Exam Pearl
Q: When should external fixation be used for floating knee injuries?
A: Indications for temporary external fixation: Damage control orthopaedics - polytrauma, hemodynamic instability; Open fractures with severe contamination awaiting soft tissue healing; Vascular injury requiring restoration of length before vascular repair; Compartment syndrome - provides stability during fasciotomy management; Severe soft tissue swelling precluding safe internal fixation. Conversion to definitive fixation typically within 7-14 days when soft tissue and systemic conditions permit.
Australian Context
Epidemiology
- Incidence: Higher rates in rural and remote Australia due to high-speed MVAs.
- Transport: Prolonged retrieval times in rural settings impact management decisions (Damage Control common).
Trauma System
- Major Trauma Centres: Definitive management at Level 1 trauma centres (e.g., Royal Melbourne, Alfred, Westmead).
- Retrieval Services: RFDS, CareFlight for rural trauma.
AOA NJRR
- The AOA National Joint Replacement Registry tracks outcomes of subsequent arthroplasty required for post-traumatic arthritis.
Guidelines
- RACS Position Statement: Polytrauma management protocols.
- State Trauma Guidelines: Victoria (VSTORM), NSW (ITIM).
Rehabilitation
- TAC/icare: Covers rehabilitation for motor vehicle trauma in VIC/NSW.
- NDIS: For patients with permanent disability requiring ongoing support.
Floating Knee Quick Reference
High-Yield Exam Summary
Fraser Classification
- •Type I: Both shafts (extra-articular) - best prognosis
- •Type IIA: Tibia articular (plateau)
- •Type IIB: Femur articular (distal femur)
- •Type IIC: Both articular - worst prognosis
Key Assessment
- •High-energy polytrauma focus
- •Knee ligament injury in 50%+
- •Compartment syndrome - thigh AND leg
- •Popliteal artery at risk
Fixation Order
- •Femur first (restores length/alignment)
- •IM nailing preferred for shafts
- •Anatomic reduction for articular components
- •Damage control if unstable
Complications
- •Knee stiffness (most common)
- •Ligament instability (often occult)
- •Compartment syndrome
- •Infection/Nonunion
References
- Fraser RD, et al. The floating knee: ipsilateral fractures of the femur and tibia. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1978.
- Rethnam U, et al. Floating knee injuries: a report of 28 cases with management and outcome. Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg. 2007.
- Szalay MJ, et al. Associated knee ligamentous injuries in patients with floating knee. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1990.
- Pape HC, et al. Damage control orthopaedics in polytrauma: what's new? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2002.